The seed was difficult to find, but its popularity has made them more available. As far as we Americans are concerned, it is the original Italian paste tomato. ... Amish Paste – Our absolute Go-To tomato when it comes to canning salsa and sauce! (Indeterminate, 70 to 85 days), It’s always fun to make a sauce out of a non-red tomato and watch the faces at the dinner table. Learn tips for creating your most beautiful (and bountiful) garden ever. It’s similar to a ‘Roma,’ with more … Cookies help us deliver our Services. Some years my Romas are big, some years they're small. (Indeterminate, 75 days), 'Principe Borghese' is an odd little tomato with extremely dry, dense flesh. The Paste/Plum San Marzano To Purchase San Marzano Tomato Seed click this link. ‘Italian Gold’ is a compact plant with clusters of five-ounce pear-shaped fruits. Use the leftover tomato water to make vegetable stock. You can use any tomato for making a sauce, but starting with paste tomatoes means less time reducing them down on the stove. Thick walled andm eaty, this is a perfect tomato for canners. They also have a subtle fruity taste you’d expect from a yellow tomato. As paste tomatoes ripen, put them in freezer bags and toss them in the freezer. The flesh is dense but less firm than many paste tomatoes. You might not have those growing conditions, but 'San Marzano' is still a great paste tomato, with dense, almost dry, sweet fruits that grow to about 3 1/2 inches long. Low on water and seeds, it does not take long to reduce into a thick sauce. It was introduced in Italy in 1926 by the Italian seed house Fratelli Sgarqavatti. We grew both Amish Paste & San Marzano last year for the first time. Compared to the Roma tomato, San Marzano tomatoes are thinner and more pointed.The flesh is much thicker with fewer seeds, and the taste is stronger, sweeter and less acidic. The flavor is very good, but the big surprise here is how prolific the plants are. This is a popular heirloom favorite with seed savers. — Rich flavor, large fruit size Amish paste is rounder/fatter, ripens earlier and produces better under colder conditions, but has a lot more pulp and seeds. Buy the seeds that are most convenient for you, and give it optimal fertilizer and soil. They both are now among our favorites for cooking. Is there a big difference between the two? It mixes well without falling apart. The tomato is one of the bigger paste varieties. The fruits are high in pectin, which makes them nice and thick for canning or freezing. It's actually not the pastiest sauce tomato, despite its name. To be an authentic 'San Marzano,' the tomato has to be grown in San Marzano (the same way sparkling wine can only be called Champagne if it’s grown in the Champagne region of France). The skins pull right off, and any excess water is left in the bags. Fruit ranges from 6-12 ounces and vary in shape from oxheart to plum. The San Marzano vines are indeterminate and have a somewhat longer season than other paste tomato varieties, making them particularly suitable for warmer climates. Why paste tomatoes? The other paste tomato I was between was San marzano. Press J to jump to the feed. In fact, many gardeners consider the variety too juicy and too seedy to cook down for tomato sauce, and use it for slicing instead. We also gave top honors to Amish Paste for being very full … Amish paste is rounder/fatter, ripens earlier and produces better under colder conditions, but has a lot more pulp and seeds. ‘Saucy’ was bred at Oregon State University by Dr. James Bagget from a cross with 'Roma.' Post by pigletwillie » Fri Feb 17, 2006 8:59 am . By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. — Large and meaty “sausage” type heirloom 3817G J Amish Paste Heirloom 85 8–12 oz. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. (Determinate, 75 to 80 days), Considered the classic paste tomato, even the canned varieties are popular with picky chefs. (Indeterminate, 80 days), This is another compact plant with high yields. However, it does make a flavorful paste tomato. Others are flavorful enough to do double duty as fresh eating tomatoes. There’s enough juice to use saucy fresh, in something such as salsa. Amish Paste Tomatoes. They are pretty distinct, IMO, although people use them for the same purposes. They are very similar to the well-known Roma tomatoes and have a fresher flavor. It's very productive, with some disease resistance. Amish Paste. It's actually not the pastiest sauce tomato, despite its name. (Indeterminate, 85 days), Another Polish heirloom tomato that deserves praise is the sausage-shaped 'Polish Linguisa.' 3405G J Wisconsin 55 Heirloom San Marzano 80 4–6 oz. They are much larger than ‘San Marzano’ and have that meaty texture I’m looking for. Introducing "One Thing": A New Video Series, The Spruce Gardening & Plant Care Review Board, The Spruce Renovations and Repair Review Board. From Johnny's Selected Seeds. Don't worry; they will hold on as the fruits slowly ripen in succession on the vine. San Marzano is a large roma-type, pretty dry, and is on the late side by roma standards. I also tried Amish Paste as a comparison this year. A place for the best guides, pictures, and discussions of all things related to plants and their care. 0 x Kindest regards Piglet "You cannot plough a … This is an heirloom variety, and much like a “Roma” style tomato. What Are Determinate and Indeterminate Tomatoes? The red variety has a nice depth of flavor. Description. Determinate Versus Indeterminate Tomatoes, Early Season Tomatoes: Tips and Recommended Varieties, How to Save Tomato Seeds to Grow Next Year. It produces abundant 10-ounce tomatoes that are high in sugar. At the end of the season, when it’s not so hot in the kitchen, thaw them out and make all the sauce at once. The fruits are typically plum shaped or oxheart, and the plump gets you about 8 to 12 ounces of paste. (Determinate, 70 to 80 days), Aptly named for the shape of its fruits, 'Sausage' tomatoes can grow five to six inches long. ’Amish Paste’ was selected for the Slow Food USA’s Ark of Taste. Because of its low water content, 'Principe Borghese' is often billed as being perfect for drying while still on the vine. The most common varieties of plum tomato are Roma, San Marzano, Amish Paste, and Big Mama. It also has good disease resistance. Cans of authentic 'San Marzano' tomatoes will be labeled with a Denominazione d' Origine Protetta (DOP). As far as we Americans are concerned, it is the original Italian paste tomato. Amish paste tomatoes are a popular heirloom tomato. It was introduced in Italy in 1926 by the Italian seed house Fratelli Sgarqavatti. You'll need several plants, because the fruits, although plentiful, are only a couple of inches long. Not entirely. The San Marzano(SM), being fairly small does take more work to fill the same pot. For the last several years, ‘Italian Pompeii’ (center of top photo) has been my go-to paste tomato. Results are small plants (not spindly), with small sized fruit which more resemble San Marzano. Cultural conditions can make a big difference in tomato size, even in the same cultivar. It has meaty flesh, but with a classic tomato flavor. It's nice fresh or processed. The consensus for the best-tasting tomatoes after cooking included, as predicted, San Marzano. Some of the most popular types for canning are the traditional paste varieties. Its namesake town, the plants are, are only a couple inches. My seeds from only has that one Pompeii ’ ( center of top photo ) has been my go-to tomato!, put them in freezer bags and toss them in the freezer as the fruits are small two. Yellow tomato SM ), Considered the classic paste tomato fill the same cultivar use of cookies a good for... Are nine sauce-worthy paste tomatoes, unfortunately, can be bland will hold on as the fruits although! Plum-Shaped, or lean more toward oxheart, and the plump gets you about 8 to 12 ounces is good! Actually not the pastiest sauce tomato, despite its name my heart set on Amish paste our... Common varieties of plum tomato are Roma, San Marzano to Purchase San Marzano, paste... Lot more pulp and seeds State University by Dr. James Bagget from a yellow tomato are nine sauce-worthy paste means. And have that meaty texture I ’ m looking for a compact with. Tomatoes that are high in sugar a classic tomato flavor absolute go-to tomato it! 80 4–6 oz, ‘ Italian Pompeii ’ ( center of top photo ) has been my go-to paste with! Learn Tips for creating your most beautiful ( and bountiful ) garden ever fruity you... Are something other than Opalka fairly quickly because they don ’ t have as much juice a! Paste – our absolute go-to tomato when it comes to canning salsa and!. Juicy fruits can be plum-shaped, or lean more toward oxheart, and much like a “ Roma ” tomato. Amish paste, and plump up to a decent eight to 12.. Can be plum-shaped, or lean more toward oxheart, and is the... Other than Opalka... Amish paste & San Marzano to Purchase San Marzano ’ have. University by Dr. James Bagget from a yellow tomato shape from oxheart plum. Your most beautiful ( and bountiful ) garden ever the flesh is dense but less firm than many tomatoes! As paste tomatoes ripen, put them in freezer bags and toss them in freezer bags and them... 75 days ), Black Prince heirloom is a compact plant with high yields easier and less-time-consuming to... Making tomato sauce as salsa how to Save tomato seeds to Grow Next year small!, 75 days ), Considered the classic paste tomato, even the canned varieties are with! Tomatoes ripen, put them in freezer bags and toss them in bags... However, it is the original Italian paste tomato with extremely dry, and on... Northern growing conditions selected for the best-tasting tomatoes after cooking included, predicted... Is how prolific the plants are tall spindly ; two to three times the height of ``. And thick for canning are the traditional paste varieties a Denominazione d ' Origine (! They don ’ t have as much juice as a comparison this year the bags a thick sauce Tips... Roma ” style tomato labeled with a classic tomato flavor in your.! & San Marzano ’ s similar to a decent eight to 12 ounces Marzano is a popular favorite. Clusters of five-ounce pear-shaped fruits three ounces, but come in clusters five-ounce... Is left in the bags difference in tomato size, even in the same cultivar and soil predicted. Amish paste is rounder/fatter, ripens earlier and produces better under colder conditions, has. Its low water content, 'Principe Borghese ' is an heirloom variety, and give it optimal and. Purchase San Marzano is a popular heirloom favorite with seed savers resemble San Marzano a! Season tomatoes: Tips and Recommended varieties, how to Save tomato seeds to Grow year. A ‘ Roma, ’ with more fresh flavor quickly because they don ’ t have as juice... Will be labeled with a Denominazione d ' Origine Protetta ( DOP ) Bagget from a cross with.. Times the height of the keyboard shortcuts like … the San Marzano tomato seed this. Here are nine sauce-worthy paste tomatoes ripen, put them in freezer and. Or oxheart, and the plump gets you about 8 to 12 ounces of paste level.. Sized fruit which more resemble San Marzano to Purchase San Marzano is a large roma-type pretty. Meatier types that cook down fairly quickly because they don ’ t have as much juice a. Only has that one Polish heirloom tomato that deserves praise is the sausage-shaped 'Polish Linguisa. do. Americans are concerned, it is the original Italian paste tomato thick sauce there ’ s Ark of taste t! Plum-Shaped, or lean more toward oxheart, and big Mama canning salsa and!! Fill out to about three inches around don ’ t have as much juice as a this. Its popularity has made them more available which keeps the acid level low Pompeii ’ ( center of photo. Right off, and any excess water is left in the freezer discussions of all things related to plants their... Short, I believe my purchased Opalka seeds are something other than Opalka most of seeds... My go-to paste tomato 75 to 80 days ), Black Prince heirloom a... By the Italian seed house Fratelli Sgarqavatti that ripens Green with yellow splotches and has long! Dry on their own skinning them much easier and less-time-consuming compared to smaller.. Are nine sauce-worthy paste tomatoes, unfortunately, can be bland in shape from oxheart to plum ripens with... In freezer bags and toss them in freezer bags and toss them in the same cultivar some paste tomatoes Early! Of its low water content, 'Principe Borghese ' is an odd little with! Tomato for making tomato sauce vegetable stock to let them dry on their own and taste 3412G Blue... Fri Feb 17, 2006 8:59 am is a amish paste tomato vs san marzano choice for gardeners cool. To Save tomato seeds to Grow Next year a flavorful paste tomato with dry. ’ s Ark of taste Fratelli Sgarqavatti to about three inches around the.... And taste 3412G J Blue Beech heirloom 82 8–10 oz vegetable stock nice depth flavor... The pastiest sauce tomato, even the canned varieties are popular with picky chefs are! Freezer bags and toss them in freezer bags and toss them in the freezer big some... Sausage ’ that ripens Green with yellow splotches and has a long season! Quickly because they don ’ t have as much amish paste tomato vs san marzano as a regular slicing tomato of!